Adopt Help Adopt Help
Want to Adopt? Click here
Adopt Help
Pregnant? Click here
Adoptive Parenting Blog

03/03/06

Myths and Fantasies

Posted by : Dr. G in Adoptive Parenting Blog at 08:19 am , 497 words, 83 views  
Categories: Adoptive Families
When I originally developed the category Myths and Fantasies for my blog, I was recalling all of the statements I've heard expressed by parents who are fantasizing about growing their family through adoption. I try to be careful not to judge anyone's reasons for expanding their families in whatever way they choose to do so. Usually, people add to their families by choice simply because they want do. I don't know if that is to be considered a so-called good reason or not. But, fundamentally that is why people choose to have children in the first place and it is why they choose to have more children.

I don't know if adoptive parents are any more prone to fanciful thinking about what their family experience is going to be like than other parents. I think most new parents are greeted with a reality checking wake-up call (no pun intended) fairly early on in the parenting process. At some point in the daily grind of parenting, when the euphoria has dissipated and there are no bells and whistles it settles in, "Oh. This is what everybody was talking about." I think most new parents adjust to this reality fairly easily. But, I think there are some fantasies about adoption that might make the adjustment a little more difficult for some (not all) adoptive parents.

SPONSOR
Adoption Associates, Inc.

Unfortunately, I have worked with a significant number of adoptive families that were near the breaking point because of child behavior problems (some attachment based, others not) in which the adoptive parents were genuinely perplexed and resentful that their child, or children, were not "grateful" for having been adopted. Usually, upon exploring this line of thought, almost to a person, these parents went into adoption with the fantasy that they were "doing the child a favor." Here is where I think the adoptive parent fantasies can be qualitatively different from the fantasies of a biological parent.

I can't ever recall a time when I've heard a biological parent say that they felt that they were doing their child a favor by having them. Of course, biological parents who bend over backwards for their children become angry and hurt if their child demonstrates obnoxious and selfish behavior. Still, that is not the same as actually having a baby to do him or her a favor. I can not count the number of times that I've heard an adoptive parent, or a parent fantasizing about adoption express what I call the parenting as charity work sentiment.

I think this is a topic worth exploring in great detail, because I believe if discussed honestly, it might offer some insight into a dynamic that is unique to adoptive families. By doing so, perhaps the parenting as charity fantasy can be revealed for what it is and replaced with a more realistic perspective. It would seem that could go a long way in reducing, if not preventing, a lot of pain and heartache and resentment for some adoptive families.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Susan [Visitor] · http://www.readingwritingliving.blogspot.com
That was a very wise post.
PermalinkPermalink 03/03/06 @ 11:17
Comment from: Sharlene [Member] Email · http://older-child.adoptionblogs.com/
Here you go again. Right on target. I know that as youth teachers for our church. Both my husband and I are guilty of that
feeling.

We went into foster care and adoption wanting to help children and siblings stay together. Now as each one gets older and flies out of the nest. They leave us behind. Treat us like we should be thankful for having them in our life.

And Oh Yes, we have asked ourselves and even discussed, "Where is the gratitude."

When the older two would get out of hand I would tell them to get an attitude of gratitude or allowances may stop. (Grin)

I am ashamed that I feel that way especially with my middle daughter.
She has put us through such turmoil and distress.

I think you have hit the nail on the head. I know my parents never expected gratitude from us. However, it just came naturally to us kids to respect and honor them.
That however is not the case with most adopted children. Very few seem to respect and honor their adoptive parents, just because they are their parents.

Ackkk, Even with all the stress I would still adopt mine again. The good far out weighs the bad on a normal basis.

Dr. G. I adore how you put things across to us.

Hugs,
Shar
PermalinkPermalink 03/03/06 @ 13:48
Comment from: Heather [Visitor]
From a different perspective, I can't count the number of times I have had people say to me "Oh that is so wonderful of you to adopt those children" like I am some heroine to save abandoned children. I feel so uncomfortable because that is so far from the truth. We are not dealing with any special needs, culture issues, etc. In fact, we adopted two healthy white children (from infants). I think our society in general projects these types of adoption stereotypes. In our situation, my husband and I are the ones that are grateful.
PermalinkPermalink 03/03/06 @ 22:09
Comment from: jayna01 [Member] Email
Pain, heartache and resentment is what you get and feel when your adoptive parent tells you how lucky you should feel because of the horrible situation they got you out of by adopting you.

I don't know where Sharlene is getting her information, but I can speak for my twin brother and I who were adopted that we honored, loved and respected our adoptive parents and many other adoptees do also.

If the truth were known, we were not always respected and loved like we should have been by our adopters. It goes both ways. We never could live up to the expectations they had for us. We were their puppets. Now years later, my dad has virtually nothing to do with us. The "fairy tale" adoption story was merely a myth or lie.

Thank you Dr. G for addressing this subject. I've never seen anyone do it, but it gives me validity to feelings I have that I knew were there in my heart.

Bless you . .
PermalinkPermalink 04/15/06 @ 01:26
Comment from: Dr. G [Member] Email · http://adoptive-parenting.adoptionblogs.com/
Thanks to all of you who commented on this post, including jayna01 (I see you just posted today!). I'm glad that I wrote about something that resonated with you and perhaps was helpful.
PermalinkPermalink 04/15/06 @ 18:34
Comment from: Marion-algier [Member] Email
I am an adoptive parent of a 21-year-old that I feel blessed to have had the opportunity to parent. The question of a thank you was never a thought because our daughter did not know she was adopted and once we had her, the thought never crossed my mind... ever. It is like thinking about your Ceasarian whenever you did something for you child and expecting them to thank you for going through that procedure.

What I resent is are the birth parents and families who give up their children, for whatever reason, get a new start and a reprieve from their responsibilities, but figure they are owed something instead of being grateful. This is not only from personal experience, but from the experiences of friends and family who have also adopted, as well as from my professional experience, working in social services. I think we have misplaced our focus a bit in the last years.
PermalinkPermalink 12/09/06 @ 05:31
Comment from: Marion-algier [Member] Email
I am an adoptive parent of a 21-year-old who I feel blessed to have had the opportunity to parent. The question of a thank you was never a thought because our daughter did not know she was adopted and once we had her, the thought never crossed my mind... ever. It is like thinking about your Ceasarian whenever you did/do something for your child and expecting them to thank you for going through that procedure.

But what I resent are the birth parents and families who give up their children, for whatever reason, get a new start and a reprieve from their responsibilities, but figure they are owed something, including thank yous for giving up their child, instead of being grateful that their child got a good home and they got a new life. I speak not only from personal experience, but from the experiences of friends and family who have also adopted, as well as from my professional experience, working in social services. I think we have misplaced our focus a bit in the last years. And adoptive parents who speak out against the present trend a looked at as malcontents.
PermalinkPermalink 12/09/06 @ 05:35
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

AdoptHelp
Choose an Option









Pregnant?
click here
AdoptHelp.com

Misc

Subscribe to Adoptive Parenting Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 133