Adopt Help Adopt Help
Want to Adopt? Click here
Adopt Help
Pregnant? Click here
Adoptive Parenting Blog

10/05/06

Adoption. What a Bummer?

Posted by : Dr. G in Adoptive Parenting Blog at 04:37 pm , 458 words, 147 views  
Categories: Celebrating Adoption
Today, my best friend, Jackie, mentioned another good friend of hers, who had been able to locate her first mother and father just a little while back. I suggested that she tell her friend about the blogs at www.adoptionblogs.com. Jackie knows that I write for the Adoptive Parenting and the Older Parent Blog and, sometimes, she reads just to see what I'm posting about. Today she shared with me that when she first started following my posts she used to scan through all the other blogs nearly every morning. Then she told me something that surprised me. She said she just stopped reading because she found it all so overwhelming and depressing. She had never mentioned that before.

What she tends to do now is check in to see if I have written anything new and if not, she moves on. This brings me back to an issue that I have mentioned before, the negative themes can become such a focus in adoption. Has the pendulum swung from the rainbows and angels singing with harps depiction of adoption to one that emphasizes only the negative?

SPONSOR

Anyone who follows my posts knows that I am motivated to share the positive view of adoption. The positive view. Not to be confused with an unrealistic view. And certainly not to be confused with a false view. But what is the view that Jackie experienced when she said she just stopped reading because it was all so overwhelming and depressing? She is not seeking to adopt any children. Her primary interest in reading about adoption is so that she can be informed about how adoption affects me and my husband, our lives, our family's life, our daughters, our son.

A casual acquaintance said to me once, "Your kids don't seem like they're adopted. They just seem normal. You always read about how adopted kids have so many issues." Then she literally shuddered. I don't know how to take a comment like that. On the one hand I want to raise the banner that says: "HEY! My kids are just like every other kid, they're just ADOPTED! However, I write for a blogging community that underscores the reality that there are "issues" for many, many adopted children.

By presenting a realistic picture of adoption are we encouraging or discouraging prospective adoptive parents? After learning about our experiences are they inspired to continue their pursuit, or are they dissuaded from doing so? After reading through our blogs do they leaving thinking, "Adoption. How neat!" Or, do they leave feeling, "Adoption. What a bummer!" If neither of those extremes is the case, what is the realistic, eyes-wide-open, middle ground response we would hope we could achieve?

"Adoption. _______!"

Can anyone fill in the blank?

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Michelle Vandepas [Member] Email · http://older-parent.adoptionblogs.com/
Dr.G.

When I first started writing I too would read all the other blogs and became overwhelmed with the negatives. I quit reading so I totally understand your friend.

I think the posts have gotten more mixed recently, showing the positive and negatives sides.

I know I try to write both, although sometimes the negative is 'more interesting'....

There are a few bloggers I've noticed that RARELY say anything negative. (The men mostly.

You've posed a great question for the fellow bloggers and the adoption community in general.

I hope you get a lot of responses.

Thanks
PermalinkPermalink 10/05/06 @ 16:49
Comment from: Sandra Hanks Benoiton [Member] Email · http://international.adoptionblogs.com/
is
PermalinkPermalink 10/05/06 @ 20:09
Comment from: Kate94651 [Member] Email
Adoption...how scary. There are stories of children with problems, sure, but that's the issue with the least impact.

Yes, I know adopted children have the right to know their biological roots. And I would never stand in the way of that. The constant beating of the "triad" drum...that your family is going to include these strangers who may or may not disrupt your family life on a whim. It is disturbing, to say the least.

I selfishly want to adopt a child into my family (who would be our second child...our first is our biological son). I don't want to have to "adopt" the biological parents as well. And it seems like if you do that, you are ridiculed for somehow cheating your child. It's a constant refrain...open, open, open...to the point of losing the identity of the family you are trying to create.

And maybe even more selfishly, I don't want to have to feel like I have to justify my parenting decisions to the "adoptive parenting" community. There is enough pressure being a parent wihtout all that additional stress of doing things "right" or "wrong." Everyone has an opinion and you can't satisfy them all. Just like with biological children, you have to do what is best for YOUR family and let the chips fall where they may. But it takes a strong personality to understand that and not be overwhelmed by the many strong opinions out there.
PermalinkPermalink 10/06/06 @ 07:07
Comment from: Dr. G [Member] Email · http://adoptive-parenting.adoptionblogs.com/
Kate, thanks for sharing that viewpoint. you might be interested in reading a post i wrote a while back about the very issues you bring up in your comment. i hope it is helpful. the link is below. if you have trouble openining it then just go the Reality category on our blog and scan through until you find two posts that are back-to-back: one on Open Adoption and the other on Closed Adoption. i hope to hear back from you after you've had a chance to read those two.

http://adoptive-parenting.adoptionblogs.com/weblogs/why-closed-adoption
PermalinkPermalink 10/06/06 @ 08:16
Comment from: Jenna Hatfield [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
Has the pendulum swung from the rainbows and angels singing with harps depiction of adoption to one that emphasizes only the negative?

Sorry, but no, adoption isn't all rainbows and butterflies. It's real. Just like the rest of life.
PermalinkPermalink 10/06/06 @ 09:01
Comment from: Stephanie [Member] Email
Adoption, They're just kids! It amazes me how many people think adoption is scary. I don't think it is at all. In fact, pregnancy scares the hell out of me, not adoption. And not all adopted kids have "issues", and the ones that do are given to parents that can and want to deal with them. There are many biological kids who have the same kinds of "issues" but somehow they are highlighted for adopted kids. I don't think you are depressing at all. You relay your experiences, and they are always infused with your obvious love of being a mom. Let's not forget your daughter is a toddler, and while she may require some extra care, she is not a monster.
PermalinkPermalink 10/06/06 @ 10:02
Comment from: Erin H [Member] Email · http://transracial.adoptionblogs.com/
Adoption, a beautiful way to build a family.

I am another "look on the bright side" of things blogger. I do post about the challenges...those regarding being a transracial family...those being an adoptive family...those in regards to adjustment and the process, etc. however, since the bulk of my life and adoption-related expereinces are wonderful, those are the glasses I see through. I share my honest feelings and outlooks...for us, adoption has truly been a beautiful way to build a family. Not perfect...not without it's challanges...but wonderful none the less.
I've been accused of not being completely honest because I don't complain enough or I don't "admit" we have enough struggles, but the reality is that I don't have a lot to complain about and my kids are all happy, well-bonded and well-adjusted.
everyone has to find the right balance for themself...Anyone who can only see the negative in adoption is missing a huge piece of the puzzle, and while it's nice to focus on the "rwinbows and angels", it is important to remember that there is always another side to the coin.

Great post. :)
E
PermalinkPermalink 10/06/06 @ 12:01
Comment from: Coley S. [Member] Email · http://unplanned-pregnancy.adoptionblogs.com/
I too have been accused of being too positive and beleive me as a birthmom I get the pain, but I don't want to spend the rest of my life focusing on the pain. I want to share the pain and the joy that are in my personal adoption situation. If this were a perfect world adoption would not exsit, but it's not a perfect world and adoption was the best decision for my child at that time and now I just have to deal with and no amount of positive posts or negative posts can change that.

I just want expectant moms to think before placing. I feel like some place too hastily not thinking of what they may feel in the future.

Enough rambling! Great post Dr. G!
PermalinkPermalink 10/07/06 @ 12:29
Comment from: binhsma [Member] Email
I am a domestic adoptee who has been reunited with her birthfamily at 45 years old.I am also a bio mom and an adoptive mom to 4 soon to be 5 adoptive children.What is adoption to me? The greatest blessing of my life! We have parented two children adopted at one year,one child adopted at 7,one at 2 &1/2 Years old and our new daughter in China will be about 3 when we go to China for her.All my adoptive children have been special needs except one.Two from Previously failed adoptions called disruptions.My 7 year old now 25 has many adult issues from her adoption and her losses in her life.Some times she loves us some times it seems she does not.Always she is our dearly loved daughter.I would not change a thing about any of our adoptions.All our children were meant to be ours and they are all claimed and all blessings to us!
Dawn
PermalinkPermalink 10/08/06 @ 12:02
Comment from: artist4mygod [Member] Email
I think you've made a valuable point. Forums like this are a great opportunity for us to "vent" a bit about the many challenges we face, but it's also a chance to encourage and build each other up, to share resources, tips and ideas.

Our first year as foster parents we attended our state's annual foster parents association retreat/training weekend. We were so excited to go and get filled with great ideas. But, when the weekend was over, we left deflated after spending almost every single session listening to foster and adoptive parents complain, grumble and vent.

We haven't been back since.
PermalinkPermalink 09/17/07 @ 23:05
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

AdoptHelp
Choose an Option









Pregnant?
click here
AdoptHelp.com

Misc

Subscribe to Adoptive Parenting Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 110