Adopt Help Adopt Help
Want to Adopt? Click here
Adopt Help
Pregnant? Click here
Adoptive Parenting Blog

02/21/06

Adoption Remorse

Posted by : Dr. G in Adoptive Parenting Blog at 08:59 am , 650 words, 294 views  
Categories: Remorse
I have been trying to figure out how to write this post. I find it "vedee ingtervesting" that I have started and stopped several times in the past couple of days. Usually when I sit down to post, my thoughts just flow. I am a motor mouth and when it comes to posting, my fingers are just an extension of my loose lips. In speaking and in writing, sometimes that is a good thing. Sometimes not. But it is who I am, who I have always been, and it is not likely to change.

You can see why I am totally shocked to find that when I decided to post on the topic of adoption remorse, all of a sudden I'm struggling with writer's block? What's up with that? So, I'm going to break this down into its manageable components. As such, this will probably be one of those Part I, Part II, Part III kinds of posts. Bear with me, dear readers.

Let's see here. The first difficult task is to tackle an honest definition of what adoption remorse means. It is quite simply, when you regret adopting your child or children, when you wish you had not done it. There, I've said it. Difficult task #1 done. Check.

SPONSOR
Adoption Associates, Inc.

I think parenting remorse happens routinely for biological parents. But, few parents ever talk about it seriously, at least not openly and honestly. What we do, instead, is joke about it.

We make light of how difficult it is being a parent with funny little stories and parent friendly jokes. That makes it okay. The humor takes the bite out of the feelings leaving open the possibilty that we don't really mean what we are saying. "Oh, I was just kidding" becomes a safe retreat.

Nevertheless, expressing parent remorse, even in disguise, can be beneficial emotionally and psychologically. Once the feelings are out, then you can roll up your sleeves and get back in the mix of things.

I have been around plenty of biological parents who joke about how wonderful life was before they had their children and how miserable they have been since having them. They openly laugh about the strain becoming a parent places on finances, time, relationships, workplace responsibilities...sex! The conversation doesn't go on long. Just long enough to register a passing sense of dissatisfcation and a longing for life as it used to be before having children. Then the whining is over and everybody resumes being a good enough parent, loving their kids to pieces, and coping with the reality of parenting.

Somehow, I don't think adoptive parents ever believe that it is okay to express adoption remorse, not even in jest. Some may feel that after years of waiting and trying to adopt they should not permit themselves to feel, let alone express, a moment of regret or doubt about their decision. Others may fear being judged harshly, and perhaps more unfairly than biological parents are judged, for having such feelings.

Maybe it is the concept itself of adoption remorse. Is that really what it is? Is it ALL simply parenting remorse? Perhaps if it were framed in that context then adoptive parents, just like any other parents, would be able to express these feelings when they come up without feeling guilty or the fear of being stigmatized.

However, in the name of "keeping it real" I am compelled to voice my opinion that that there is something qualitatively different about parenting remorse when you have become a parent through adoption as opposed through giving birth to your child. And now, hard task # 2. I know. Because,I, have been there.

Whew boy! Alrighty. This is all I can write for now. I'll return to conintue on with my thoughts later. (If I dare.) Meanwhile, feel free to jump in and help me out here and post comments of your own. This is a toughie.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Heather Lowe [Member] Email · http://unplanned-pregnancy.adoptionblogs.com/
Great post; looking forward to reading more. I believe all parents experience regrets/remorse at one time or another.

I also see why it's much harder for adoptive parents to admit to those type of feelings. Glad you are brave and honest enough to acknowledge the complexities behind becoming a parent. My son's adoptive parents also voiced this and I was glad to hear it--it made them seem more human and real to me.
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 09:28
Comment from: Nancy Spoolstra [Member] Email · http://attachment-disorder.adoptionblogs.com/
I'm lovin' this already Dr. G. Surprisingly enough, I didn't feel adoption remorse until pretty darn late in the game... or maybe I should say, I didn't RECOGNIZE or ACKNOWLEDGE any remorse until much later. It was after about a decade of parenting my "flatliner" daughter, after trying and failing to motivate, change, move or affect her. I found myself asking myself... why did I choose to build my family like this, after all? What if I had just had 4 bio kids instead of adding such challenging kids to the mix by adoption? My bio kids were and are very easy, and they are very successful in the ways parents hope their kids to be successful. Not so with my older adoptees... but then I realize, if I hadn't taken the path I did, I wouldn't have Hannah, wouldn't have started ADN, wouldn't have appreciated my bio kids like I do now, wouldn't be nearly the person I have become because of my trials and tribulations. AND, my two older adoptees wouldn't have had the opportunities they have had, wouldn't perhaps be as far as they are, even if it isn't as far as I want them to be... Can't wait to see what else you write about this!
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 09:28
Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthfamily-search.adoptionblogs.com/
I have a theory about this from a birth mom's view. To acknowledge any uncertainty might subject an adoptive parent to being judged for adopting in the first place.

After all, people put you all on those pedestals, right? And, I believe that since adoptive parents "volunteer" for the job of parenting, they are and should be subjected to greater scrutiny. In a way by adopting, one is saying to the world, "I am worthy" to parent. To acknowledge that maybe you aren't so certain after all....is a bit of a dilemma I think. The "other" parent may have had doubts about being capable of parenting, but, YOU are not supposed to, right?

Make any sense to you?
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 10:42
Comment from: Dr. G [Member] Email · http://adoptive-parenting.adoptionblogs.com/
Exactly! But, I think this is a false dilemma. It seems like we, as a society, are so skittish about how we want to view adoptive parents. One minute there is the whole "real parent" debate going on. You know the one. Adoptive parents are the real parents. The next minute, we're making them feel like they aren't allowed to have the same real feelings that real parents have. That's crazy making to me.
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 10:53
Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthfamily-search.adoptionblogs.com/
Adoption is confusing and full of complexities if nothing else. Just like you aren't allowed to be "real" neither are birth parents. You know, we gave up our rights,etc. so we aren't REALLY parents anymore. While we do not "parent" our relinquished children, motherhood and fatherhood still remain. Both sets of parents are real. But, both are often told that we aren't. Go figure!

Crazy-making? Oh yeah, there's a boatload of that!
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 11:35
Comment from: Fertility Blog Archive [Member] Email
Dr. G--

Wow, what a great, honest, tough post. Helpful for those of us contemplating adoption.

There is this "split" as well in the disabled community (our son is disabled). The majority of the parents and the resulting parenting groups are the "this is such a gift," "I wouldn't want it any other way" blah blah blah.

Delusional! I was so happy to find a group where we felt ok to express our true and often unattractive feelings. On many many days, we wish our kids weren't the way they were and that they were "normal". I think that's important to admit and express. Forget the pasted on holier-than-thous-martyr stuff. I like my margarita-swilling "sisters" better, and we are healthier for it...my two cents.

best,
marie
http://infertility.adoptionblogs.com
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 12:07
Comment from: Nancy Spoolstra [Member] Email · http://attachment-disorder.adoptionblogs.com/
Gee, Marie, your comment is thought-provoking too. It isn't a surprise that the disabled community has the same dynamics, but you only think about what you know... that frame of reference thing again. Thanks for opening my eyes!
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 16:43
Comment from: Adrienne Bashista [Member] Email · http://russia.adoptionblogs.com/
I think this also relates to the pain/loss of infertility. The times when I've felt remorse about my adopted child (I admit to this honestly) it hasn't been so much about him as about grieving the others that we lost or that we never knew.
When you want something so badly and then what you get isn't quite what you expected...it can be very painful. But eating the pain is worse than expressing it, I think.
Great post.
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 16:48
Comment from: Peanut [Visitor]
In my opinion you could take this theory much further. For me my extended family are even less willing to cut us any parenting slack (room for doubts or error) than the are those with the bio kids, because well "You signed up for this," and "You knew adopting would be different,so don't act so surprised." Even among my children's birth family if we do not hold up to this ideal of somehow "perfect" parenting (or at least as they expected) then we get criticised twice as hard as their family member who chose not to parent at all. Somedays the whole mess of how others (on both sides) judge my husband and I makes me want to run away from them all. I love my kids, we have a great family and how it works when those others are not around scrutinizing our every move is really how it should be, good and bad. The rest of the "clan" both birth family and extended adoptive family need to stop trying to squeeze MY FAMILY into their ideal. We are what we are & it works, period.
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 17:03
Comment from: Mich [Visitor] · http://www.gotchababy.blogspot.com
When the Babe was a few weeks old, I ran into a fellow adoptive parent at the library. She asked how things were going, and I responded that we were REALLY tired, but doing Ok. She then said to me something I'll never forget. She said, "You know, I felt like when our boys came home we were supposed to be so happy all the time-like people thought we shouldn't ever complain because we chose to be in our current situation. Let me tell you--it isn't always easy, and you're allowed to be frustrated and tired, just like every other mom on the planet. So if you need to whine or complain and don't think others will take it the right way, give me a call!"

That made my day.

And I think it's true--adoptive parents are a little scared to complain/think "what in the heck have we gotten ourselves into?" because becoming parents didn't happen "the easy way" and we've made a conscious decision to do this.

But we're all human. I wouldn't call it "remorse", but just a "WTF was I thinking?!?" moment. Then it passes, and life goes on ;-)
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 17:11
Comment from: Julie [Member] Email · http://special-needs.adoptionblogs.com/
Marie,

I can relate! Guess I have a double dose of remorse, since my disabled child is adopted! But it is definitely hard to act like you've been nominated for sainthood all the time, when in reality you are really thinking "WHAT WAS I THINKING?" My hubby and I frequently look at each other and say -- "Whose idea was this anyway?" And then we diffuse it with laughter. We have lots of non-adoptive friends though, who we can't say that around - unless they have babysat for us -- then they start to get it:-)

Thanks Dr. G -- looking forward to Parts II & III!!!
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 17:23
Comment from: Dr. G [Member] Email · http://adoptive-parenting.adoptionblogs.com/
Oh Peanut! At some point you've GOT to consider purchasing a copy of my book "Put It On Your Therapy List: Guilt-Free Parenting In A Child-Centered World" for all of the folks in your life who are trying to squeeze your family into their ideal. I love that phrase. I'm making some changes to it right now, but it will be available again soon on my other blog (www.pioytl.blogspot.com) I'm trying not to plug it every chance I get, but your post just make me "wanna holla" and "throw my hands up in the air." (a reference to an old Marvin Gaye song). But, really that kind of stuff drives me CRAZY!
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 17:24
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

AdoptHelp
AdoptHelp
AdoptHelp
AdoptHelp

Misc

Subscribe to Adoptive Parenting Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 121